ARTICLES
Welcome to Cubby Images Articles. Each month we will be posting a new article to cover a variety of climbing topics. For future reference, all articles will be archived at the bottom of the page. If there's a topic you'd like us to cover, feel free to add a comment and we'll see what we can do.
COMMITTED - film review by Jo George
Thursday, November 08, 2007
After the huge success of the film E11, following the story of Dave MacLeod’s trials and tribulations during his attempts and final ascent of the word’s first E11, Rhapsody, the film makers, Hot Aches, had a hard act to follow.
Like Hard Grit, Rhapsody (and E11) propelled the UK’s hard trad climbing scene into the limelight and caught the attention of the climbing media worldwide. The Hot Aches team have now produced a second film about hard trad climbing with Committed – the title says it all!
Committed is the end result of a busy year’s filming of cutting edge traditional climbing from across the UK. It features some of the Britain’s top trad climbers, plus a handful from overseas, climbing some of the most difficult and dangerous climbs on the mountains and crags in Ireland, England’s Peak District, Wales and Scotland. Although I don’t feel this film has the strength of the story that E11 had (and I perhaps shouldn’t be comparing them), Committed still manages to get into the headspace of some of these top trad climbers which makes for interesting viewing, and watching their styles, techniques, method and motivation needed to achieve these hard first ascents, bold solos and audacious repeats, is certainly inspiring.
Dave MacLeod on the 3rd ascent of Trauma (E9) - an interesting comparison watching both James Pearson making the second and Dave making the 3rd.
Photo: copyright Hot Aches
The film covers a few of the hard trad routes of the 80’s and 90’s and it was good to see some of ‘the old school’ in the film, Dunne, Dawes and Dixon, all giving their thoughts on the climbs of today and proving they’re not past it yet either! Dave MacLeod turns his attention to Dawe’s 80’s test piece, Indian Face and after much deliberation, has to make a decision as to whether the risk involved in climbing such a route is worth it. The danger aspect of head-pointing at this level is apparent throughout the film and shows climbers pushing themselves to their limit, two ground falls, and Katherine Schirrmacher trying to make sense of why some climbers are good at this style of climbing and why more people aren’t hurting themselves.
The film covers a few of the hard trad routes of the 80’s and 90’s and it was good to see some of ‘the old school’ in the film, Dunne, Dawes and Dixon, all giving their thoughts on the climbs of today and proving they’re not past it yet either! Dave MacLeod turns his attention to Dawe’s 80’s test piece, Indian Face and after much deliberation, has to make a decision as to whether the risk involved in climbing such a route is worth it. The danger aspect of head-pointing at this level is apparent throughout the film and shows climbers pushing themselves to their limit, two ground falls, and Katherine Schirrmacher trying to make sense of why some climbers are good at this style of climbing and why more people aren’t hurting themselves.
Photo: copyright Hot Aches
We follow an interesting mix of personalities in their quest for that hard trad tick, including cool American, Sonnie Trotter, attempting Rhapsody; Adam Long demonstrating his immaculate grit stone technique with E6 and E8 solos and Aussie climber Ben Cossey chatting casually as he solos up a grit E8. Women are represented, both in a supportive role to their partners and at the cutting edge. Germany’s Jude Spanken on-sights Wales’ classic Lord of the Flies (a bold and serious E6) in beautiful style, while Katherine talks herself successfully up a delicate E7 arete in the Peak. Throughout the film we follow in more depth, the climbs being done by two of the leading trad climbers of today, James Pearson and Dave MacLeod. James is an exceptionally modest and talented young climber who achievements include climbing E10 at age 19 (with Equilibrium) and flashing V13 twice. Dave of course has climbed E11 and is renowned as one of the world’s best all-rounders. Watching them trying the hardest lines, often in less than ideal conditions (and in the dark!), is intriguing.
Photo: copyright Hot Aches
However, this film isn’t all about the hardest lines being climbed, it’s as much about being “committed” and Kev Shields shows a shining example of that. Kev has much of his left hand missing and as such finds it difficult to place gear and use certain holds. Despite this handicap, he puts his life on the line for his enjoyment of the sport. We also follow other Scots to the remote island of Pabbay and show commitment in another sense with frightening new routing on these spectacular sea cliffs.
The locations in the film are varied and really show the diversity and climbing styles that make the British trad scene so unique and respected around the world. The footage of the beautiful island of Pabbay made me proud to be Scottish, while America’s Trotter’s remarks that Dumbarton Rock is a beautiful place left me smiling! Those who have been to Dumbarton Rock will know why.
Unlike many climbing films, the pace of Committed is slow to steady, not hyped up. The people and climbs make it, not loud motivating music. The filming is unpretentious with some sensitive footage, the climbers are modest and the storyline, which examines the diversity of climbing style and locations, that together make the British trad scene unique and respected around the world, is an interesting one. The Extras however were a little disappointing with the exception of Keen Youth. All in all, a very good film, definitely worth purchasing, and one which you will watch over and over again. (I’ve watched it four times total so far!).
And finally I’d have to say the Hot Aches team must have been as Committed as the climbers in this film – a lot of climbs to film in one year given the diverse locations and the good old British weather. Nice one boys!
Committed is on sale now from http://www.hotaches.com/ at £19.99
Unlike many climbing films, the pace of Committed is slow to steady, not hyped up. The people and climbs make it, not loud motivating music. The filming is unpretentious with some sensitive footage, the climbers are modest and the storyline, which examines the diversity of climbing style and locations, that together make the British trad scene unique and respected around the world, is an interesting one. The Extras however were a little disappointing with the exception of Keen Youth. All in all, a very good film, definitely worth purchasing, and one which you will watch over and over again. (I’ve watched it four times total so far!).
And finally I’d have to say the Hot Aches team must have been as Committed as the climbers in this film – a lot of climbs to film in one year given the diverse locations and the good old British weather. Nice one boys!
Committed is on sale now from http://www.hotaches.com/ at £19.99
How to Climb Hard Trad - a review by Jo George
Wednesday, November 07, 2007
I think I’m one of those slightly cynical climbers who tend to dismiss like the idea of learning through books or videos – surely climbing is about getting out there and learning for yourself and being creative, coming up with your own methods. I have tended to shun books such as How to Climb 5.12 and Rockfax’s SportClimbing (The positive approach to improving your climbing), without having even read them through. For me personally it’s the unknown in climbing which I enjoy. I like to learn through my own experiences (and mistakes) and that’s probably why it’s taken me so long to learn many of the basics. I quickly learnt how to move on rock but it took years to learn how to set up a belay properly and even now I only know three knots. I think that’s called stubbornness, perhaps even stupidity.
Maybe I’m trying to rebel against what I see as this modern day’s ‘nanny’ culture where everything is laid out on a plate, minimal effort. How many times have I heard the old folk say you can’t find good hard workers these days! Pre packaged food, automated phone systems, we don’t even like walking to the post box anymore, it’s all texts and e-mails (now I’m diverging and sounding old)! Maybe this attitude is behind the times or a tad ignorant or arrogant (why don’t I want to learn from those with the experience)…or maybe I just prefer to learn my own way. Perhaps it’s a tad hypocritical too as I’ve picked up books on how to make pebble mosaics or how to work with green wood, so what’s the difference with a book on how to climb?
Maybe I’m trying to rebel against what I see as this modern day’s ‘nanny’ culture where everything is laid out on a plate, minimal effort. How many times have I heard the old folk say you can’t find good hard workers these days! Pre packaged food, automated phone systems, we don’t even like walking to the post box anymore, it’s all texts and e-mails (now I’m diverging and sounding old)! Maybe this attitude is behind the times or a tad ignorant or arrogant (why don’t I want to learn from those with the experience)…or maybe I just prefer to learn my own way. Perhaps it’s a tad hypocritical too as I’ve picked up books on how to make pebble mosaics or how to work with green wood, so what’s the difference with a book on how to climb?
Well Dave MacLeod e-mailed (I’d call him lazy for not walking to that post box if he hadn’t climbed E11! ; ) to see if I wanted to review his new 42-page e-book, How to Climb Hard Trad. This book was written as a companion to the new Committed film (see review at www……..). My first thought was oh no, surely you learn how to climb ‘hard trad’ through experience and dedication, not through a book telling you how to do it! But that is not necessarily Dave’s aim. In his own words, Dave felt that "the film was a great showcase of what is going on right now at the living end of world trad climbing. Inspiring stuff – but I know from experience as a coach that some climbers will watch the action thinking "I could never do that". I hope from reading these chapters you will see that the ascents in the film are not really as impossible as they seem, merely the end result of a process of actions that anyone can follow. You can if you want to".So I started reading and truth be told, from the first page my interest was captured.
Dave has several great credentials for writing such a mini book; he is one of the best traditional climbers in the world; he has a degree in sports psychology; his motivation is legendary and he is an excellent writer. Although the e-book is called how to climb ‘hard’ trad, it is actually aimed at climbers of all abilities, as what is hard for one climber may not be for another. In fact Dave writes, "beginners have far more to gain from adoption of good tactics because performance is so sensitive to even the smallest improvements in practice at this stage". His belief is that by applying the techniques and mindsets along with a large amount of dedication and a desire to want to get better, a climber of any ability could climb hard trad. The "desire" to want to is key and Dave writes "ultimately, pure desire to get better and experience the good feelings this brings will end up as your limiting factor".
The book is in three parts entitled 1) How to on-sight hard trad, 2) Head-pointing – why bother? And 3) Head-pointing – the guide. In part one Dave explains what on-sight climbing is and what you can do to help "tip the scales in your favour". This includes gathering information about the climb before your attempt (but not too much because it is on-sight!), dealing with danger, motivation and boldness and getting committed. He offers much useful advice on tactics, techniques, thought processes and practical methods for the climber to consider, including how to get over the fear of falling (which in many cases is what limits us).
In part one I found it very interesting to read psychologists theories on motivation and I think whether these theories are applied to climbing or all aspects of life (or both), it’s worth reading.In part two Dave explains what a climber can gain from in experience, learning and enjoyment by head-pointing climbs, and not only at the highest levels. And in part three he talks us through choosing the right climb to get you inspired, how to head-point without a belayer (very useful), strategies of rehearsing the climb, mental preparation and making it as safe as possible. Again I enjoyed reading his psychological strategies for the final head-point attempt, " the silent mind" versus the "aggressive psyche up", versus " the white noise psyche" (you’ll have to read it yourself to find out what the latter one is!).
All in all this e-book gives a great an insight into what steps you can take to improve your grade, your technique, and get pleasure out trying hard, whether you want to apply this to the hardest, boldest routes or not. I would say it’s definitely worth a read and you’ll learn something new at whatever level you’re at. An inspiring and educational read and by the end of the book I was really quite motivated and inspired to have a go at head-pointing myself.
By looking at what Dave himself has achieved, we can opt to follow his hard won advice and learn for our own improvement. So can reading this book lead to great grades? ... yes, if you want it enough!
Now maybe I’ll read SportClimbing+ !
END
The How to Climb Hard Trad e-book is free when you order the new Committed DVD. This 42 page A4 printable PDF e-book will be emailed to you once your order is confirmed - it won’t be available anywhere else. To order your copy of the film visit http://www.davemacleod.com/
The How to Climb Hard Trad e-book is free when you order the new Committed DVD. This 42 page A4 printable PDF e-book will be emailed to you once your order is confirmed - it won’t be available anywhere else. To order your copy of the film visit http://www.davemacleod.com/
December 2004 January 2005 January 2006 July 2006 October 2006 November 2007





